Striking Workers at Hilton Hawaiian Village

In a developing situation at the Hilton Hawaiian Village, the ongoing workers’ strike has highlighted a significant inconsistency within Hawaii’s unemployment benefits law. The workers, who are fighting for better wages and a larger workforce, may find themselves in a precarious position when it comes to filing for unemployment.

Many of these employees are preparing to apply for unemployment benefits, but the complexity of Hawaii’s laws may leave them in limbo for years regarding their eligibility. The key issue revolves around the impact of the strike on the hotel’s financial performance. If the strike significantly disrupts operations and leads to a major reduction in revenue, workers could be denied benefits.

As Hilton Bellman Garrett Vincent pointed out, the lack of income during the strike makes unemployment payments crucial. He shared, “I told my kids, we’re sorry. We’re not gonna go to McDonald’s. I told my wife, sorry. We can’t go to Target for next few days.”

The law stipulates that if the strike has little or no impact on the hotel’s operations, workers remain eligible for unemployment benefits. However, if the hotel loses 20 to 30 percent or more of its revenue due to the strike, the workers do not qualify for unemployment. This creates a paradox where the very aim of a strike—to pressure the employer—could result in the workers losing their safety net.

Scott Badiocchi, chair of the House Labor Committee, explained that the law is designed to support workers while also protecting the employers. He stated, “If the strike is to such an extent that the whole business gets shut down, especially a crucial business like a hospital, then unemployment benefits are withheld as perhaps, incentive not to do that.”

This situation leads to a contentious dynamic between employers and employees. Employers can contest unemployment claims by demonstrating that the strike did not significantly disrupt business operations, which can lead to a lengthy and complicated dispute process. This often requires the employer to disclose financial records, which unions may challenge.

The complexities of these cases can result in prolonged reviews, with each claim being unique. For instance, nurses previously locked out from Kapiolani Hospital faced similar issues, with their claims still under review despite the hospital’s continued operation.

Even with labor’s political influence in Hawaii, there is hesitation to push for legislative changes to the unemployment law. Many fear that altering the law could lead to unfavorable outcomes for workers, potentially diminishing their benefits.

As the strike continues, the uncertainty surrounding unemployment benefits adds another layer of stress for the workers at the Hilton Hawaiian Village, who are already facing significant financial hardships.

Shane

See Full Bio